Ugly Love vs Heart Bones: Which is Better?

“Ugly Love” by Colleen Hoover and “Heart Bones” by Colleen Hoover are both captivating novels that delve into complex emotions and relationships, each offering its own unique narrative and thematic elements.

Comparing and contrasting these two books involves exploring their characters, storytelling styles, emotional depth, and impact on readers.


“Ugly Love” follows the story of Tate Collins and Miles Archer, intertwining past and present to unravel their deep emotional scars.

The narrative is emotionally charged, exploring themes of love, loss, and the intricacies of human connections.

Colleen Hoover crafts the story with intense emotional depth, offering readers a raw and poignant exploration of trauma and the healing power of love.

On the other hand, “Heart Bones” presents a different narrative featuring Beyah, a troubled teenager sent to spend the summer with her estranged father.

This novel explores themes of self-discovery, forgiveness, and the complexities of family dynamics.

Through the backdrop of a coastal town, Colleen Hoover weaves a tale of secrets, emotional barriers, and the transformative nature of relationships.

Character Development

In terms of character development, both books excel in creating multi-dimensional characters with intricate backstories.

In “Ugly Love,” Tate and Miles are portrayed with emotional depth, their vulnerabilities and past traumas shaping their present selves.

The progression of their relationship is marked by a blend of passion, pain, and a search for healing.

Conversely, “Heart Bones” focuses on Beyah’s journey of self-discovery as she navigates her fractured family dynamics and confronts her own insecurities.

The character growth and revelations within this novel are subtle yet profound, allowing readers to witness Beyah’s transformation as she grapples with her past and confronts her present circumstances.


The storytelling styles in both books differ significantly. “Ugly Love” employs a dual narrative technique, alternating between Tate’s present-day experiences and Miles’ past, gradually revealing the reasons behind his emotional walls.

This approach keeps readers engaged and emotionally invested, unraveling the characters’ complexities layer by layer.

Meanwhile, “Heart Bones” follows a more linear storytelling method, allowing the plot to unfold steadily, revealing secrets and conflicts that keep readers captivated.

Colleen Hoover’s skillful prose draws readers into the coastal setting, creating an immersive experience that complements the emotional depth of the characters.

The emotional impact of these novels resonates deeply with readers, albeit in different ways.

“Ugly Love” grips readers with its intense emotions, evoking empathy and compassion for the characters’ pain and their journey toward healing.

It explores themes of love and sacrifice, leaving a lasting impression on readers long after they finish the book.

“Heart Bones,” on the other hand, resonates through its themes of self-acceptance, forgiveness, and the importance of confronting one’s past.

The emotional connections forged between the characters, coupled with the evocative setting, leave a poignant impression on readers, inspiring reflection on the complexities of relationships and the significance of personal growth.

Final Conclusion on Ugly Love vs Heart Bones: Which is Better?

Ultimately, determining which book is “better” is subjective and depends on individual preferences.

Both “Ugly Love” and “Heart Bones” excel in portraying deeply emotional stories, offering compelling narratives, and creating relatable characters that resonate with readers on an emotional level.

Whether one prefers the intense emotional journey of “Ugly Love” or the introspective exploration of relationships in “Heart Bones,” both novels stand as powerful examples of Colleen Hoover’s storytelling prowess, leaving a lasting impact on those who immerse themselves in their pages.


No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *